Deescalation-oriented conflict coverage? The Northern Ireland and Israeli-Palestinian peace processes in the German press
نویسنده
چکیده
Various scholars and media researchers have adopted the view, that due to the Cold War, war discourse has become the dominant discourse in Western media and popular culture. We live in a deeply militarized culture in which for instance many ordinary metaphors have their roots in war and popular culture is full of war material. Consuming war as a natural part of everyday entertainment, the "war logic" has become a naturalized way of outlining social reality and international life (Luostarinen, 2000a). As the previous "classical" war with clear phases like preparations, fight and demilitarization was replaced with continious arms race and low intensity warfare during the Cold War, both, the military and the civilian population had to be maintained in military preparedness for decades, and a permanent atmosphere of crisis was created (Luostarinen & Ottosen, 2000). The boundaries between war and peace became unclear and vague, and penetration of militarized logic into journalism was one of the consequences. Almost every single piece of news could be used for the purposes of the Cold War, and even innocent looking entertainment had potential ideological background (Whitfield, 1996). As a consequence of the Cold War culture the media and national defence organisations integrated in a way which compromised journalistic independence, and the dominance of military thinking distorted cultural and political perspectives in the media content (Luostarinen & Ottosen, 2000). While the governmental rhetoric of power and violence was adopted by the media as the official discourse, "peace talk" was tagged Communist, and got low entry into the general audience media. According to Dov Shinar (1998), this preference of war discourses resulted in a far reaching absence of a peace discourse in the media professional repertoire, and Dov Shinar, finally, comes to the conclusion that the invention of a media peace discourse should be included in the current research agenda.
منابع مشابه
The Rise and Fall of the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process
This article examines the rise and fall of the Peace Process and questions the reason for which the United States of America was successful in bringing the two sides to the negotiating table during the 1990s. It investigates the reason for which the process ultimately failed, as well as the reason for which Washingtonwas unsuccessful in restarting the peace process in the past decade. It is arg...
متن کاملCoverage of the Second Intifada and the Gaza War in the German quality press
In recent years German media coverage of the Middle East conflict has been accused of an anti-Israeli bias that reinforces old, widely held prejudices and stereotypes about Jews and supports the common accusation that Israel misuses the tragedy of the Holocaust to justify anti-Palestinian policies. In particular, there is the accusation that during and after the Gaza War the media portrayed Isr...
متن کاملThe Urgent Need for More Applicability in Peace Economics
To start, I shall criticize my own work. Take the paper on page 9 following this article. It purports to be a succinct statement of the topics and concerns of peace economics. It states "Central to the field are analyses of conflicts among nations, regions and other communities of the world; measures to control (de-escalate) arms races and achieve reduction in military expenditures and weaponry...
متن کاملPeaceMaker: A Video Game to Teach Peace
PeaceMaker is a computer game simulation of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It is a tool that can be used to teach Israeli and Palestinian teenagers how both sides can work together to achieve peace. The player can choose to take the role of either the Israeli Prime Minister or the Palestinian President, react to in-game events, and interact with other political leaders and social groups to e...
متن کاملThiel On the interaction between media frames and individual frames of the Israeli - Palestinian con -
The present paper reports on a media effects research experiment in which six groups of participants were asked to read and evaluate differently framed news articles about two scenarios: a Palestinian attack on Israel and an Israeli military operation against Palestinians. The experimental results show that media peace frames of violent events in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are generally r...
متن کامل